As India's economy and urban infrastructure continue to expand, a significant trend has emerged: land appreciation in Tier 2 cities is outpacing rental returns in Tier 1 cities. This shift has been largely driven by evolving urban development, affordability, and the expanding scope of real estate as an investment vehicle beyond traditional Tier 1 markets. Supported by data and research reports, this article delves into why Tier 2 cities are providing stronger growth in property value, especially through land appreciation, as compared to the relatively moderate rental yields in Tier 1 cities.
1. The Growth of Tier 2 Cities: A Snapshot of Urban Expansion
Several recent studies, such as the Knight Frank India Real Estate Report 2023 and JLL's Future Cities Study 2022, indicate that Tier 2 cities like Indore, Jaipur, Lucknow, and Chandigarh are witnessing growth rates rivalling, and in some cases, surpassing those of Tier 1 cities. Driven by infrastructural investments, these cities have developed robust economic hubs, allowing for enhanced employment opportunities and lifestyle amenities that were once exclusive to Tier 1 cities.
According to JLL, these cities have benefited from government initiatives like the Smart Cities Mission, aimed at improving urban infrastructure and smart solutions for efficient urban planning. With cities becoming more liveable and connected, land prices in Tier 2 cities have witnessed steady appreciation of 8-12 per cent annually, compared to 4-6 per cent in Tier 1 cities.
2. High Demand and Land Appreciation in Tier 2 Cities
The affordability of property in Tier 2 cities has also been a significant factor in their growing popularity among investors. NITI Aayog's 2023 Real Estate Investment Report reveals that the average property prices in Tier 2 cities range between ₹4,000-₹12,000 per square foot, compared to ₹20,000-₹50,000 in Tier 1 cities like Mumbai, Delhi, and Bangalore. As a result, investors and buyers are attracted by the relatively low entry cost and high potential for appreciation.
The same report highlights that land investments in these cities are yielding average returns of 10-12 per cent annually, which is significantly higher than Tier 1 cities. As the demand for land in these locations grows—fueled by an influx of industries, especially IT, manufacturing, and logistics—the value of land continues to climb.
3. Comparison of Tier 1 Rental Yields vs. Tier 2 Appreciation
In Tier 1 cities, real estate has traditionally been an income-generating asset, primarily through rental yields. However, the ANAROCK Property Consultants Rental Yield Report (2023) highlights that rental yields in Tier 1 cities have stagnated at around 2-3% per annum, which barely keeps up with inflation. This has diminished the appeal of Tier 1 property for pure income-focused investors, making Tier 2 cities a more attractive investment alternative.
Consider the following example:
Tier 1 City Rental Returns: If an investor purchases a property in a Tier 1 city for ₹1 crore, the rental income at 2.5 per cent yield will generate approximately Rs 2,50,000 annually. Over a 10-year period, with minimal capital appreciation, the total projected value is around ₹1.57 crore.
Tier 2 City Land Appreciation: In contrast, investing ₹1 crore in land in a Tier 2 city with 10 per cent annual appreciation will yield a significantly higher return. By year 10, the projected value is around ₹2.6 crore, reflecting the strong appreciation potential in these markets.
In terms of XIRR (Extended Internal Rate of Return), Tier 2 cities demonstrate a clear advantage, with an XIRR of approximately 10% compared to 4.4 per cent for Tier 1 rental returns.
4. Factors Driving Growth in Tier 2 Cities
a) Government Policies and Infrastructure Projects
The Indian government has allocated substantial funds toward infrastructure development in Tier 2 cities. Under the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) and Smart Cities Mission, cities like Indore, Surat, and Bhopal have received upgrades in road connectivity, public transportation, and digital infrastructure, positioning them as future growth centres.
b) Cost of Living and Affordable Housing
A study by ICRA (2023) indicated that Tier 2 cities offer a 30-40% lower cost of living than Tier 1 cities, making them attractive relocation destinations for young professionals and retirees. This influx is increasing demand for residential and commercial real estate, further driving land appreciation.
c) Rising Job Opportunities
With companies seeking lower operational costs, many are moving to Tier 2 cities. For instance, IT and e-commerce companies like TCS and Amazon are expanding their offices in Tier 2 locations, providing job opportunities that boost demand for housing and increase property values.
5. Future Outlook: Why Land Appreciation May Continue to Outperform Rental Yields
The future of Tier 2 real estate markets looks promising as these cities continue to develop their infrastructure, attract investments, and improve living standards. Experts from Colliers India predict that Tier 2 cities will continue to show annualized appreciation rates of 8-10 per cent over the next decade. In contrast, rental yields in Tier 1 cities are expected to remain low, constrained by high property prices and slower capital appreciation.
Given this trend, investing in Tier 2 cities offers a clear advantage for those seeking long-term wealth creation through real estate. The appeal lies in the potential for strong appreciation in a market still maturing, coupled with lower entry costs compared to Tier 1 cities.
Conclusion
The shift in India's real estate market from high-cost rental properties in Tier 1 cities to appreciating land in Tier 2 cities underscores a transformative opportunity. As research data reveals, land appreciation in Tier 2 cities like Indore, Jaipur, and Lucknow has emerged as a more lucrative investment path, consistently beating rental returns in Tier 1 cities. For investors seeking higher returns and a diversified portfolio, Tier 2 cities present a compelling case, poised to deliver strong growth as they move to the forefront of India’s real estate landscape.
_20240428142749original_image_31.webp)
_20240928152429_original_image_24.webp)
